American Bar Association President William T. (Bill) Robinson III submitted a comment letter to the U.S. Department of Labor on behalf of the
“By expressing concerns over the proposed rule and urging the department to reconsider,” wrote Mr. Robinson, “the
The proposed rule threatens to undermine Congress's intent by nullifying the advice exemption included in the original act and, if adopted, the rule would require lawyers to disclose a substantial amount of confidential client information, including the identity of the client, the general nature of the legal representation and a description of the legal tasks performed. The proposed rule also would require lawyers to disclose a great deal of confidential financial information about clients that is unrelated to persuader activities the act intends to monitor.
The department's proposed rule could also seriously undermine both the confidential client-lawyer relationship and the employers' fundamental right to counsel. To encourage trust and candor between the client and its lawyer, their exchanges must be confidential. “Only in this way can the lawyer engage in a full and frank discussion of the relevant legal issues with the client and provide appropriate legal advice,” Mr. Robinson wrote. By requiring clients and their lawyers to report confidential client information to the government, Mr. Robinson warned, “the proposed rule could very well discourage many employers from seeking the expert legal representation they need.”